I Could Not Have Said It Any Better
Fishing etiquette, sometimes I have to wonder if anyone’s ever heard of such a thing. The word etiquette is defined as: The forms required by good breeding, or prescribed by authority, to be observed in social or official life; observance of the proprieties of rank and occasion; conventional decorum; ceremonial code of polite society.
So why is it that as soon as I get on a river, I invariably end up fishing near someone who has never heard the above definition? It seems as if as soon as people get into a fishing situation, all rules of society are thrown out the window and it becomes a free for all. I mean it says, right in the definition, ‘ceremonial codes of polite society’. When it comes to fishing, especially on a river, one of those ‘ceremonial codes of polite society’ is to allow other anglers there personal space just as you would afford them in any other social situation. I mean, for God’s sake, just because were out on the river fishing it doesn’t mean that we have to become complete inconsiderate idiots, does it?
I’m of course referring to a situation that I got caught up in, not too long ago, on one of my local rivers. I had been fishing along a very nice stretch of water for about twenty minutes, when a couple of other fishermen came walking along the river. They kept there distance as we exchanged friendly glances, and they began fishing about fifty yards from where I was.
This is how things are supposed to work when two anglers meet on a river. But then I caught a fish. Then another one and this second fish was quite nice. A nice eighteen to twenty inch Rainbow. I released the fish and went on about my business, continuing to fish this nice stretch of river, which incidentally was no bigger, the average driveway.
The next thing I knew, the other fishermen were in my freakin’ back pocket! I mean these guys surrounded me like I was trying to do something horrible to one of their children. Then the interrogation started. What are you using? How big was that fish? Do you always catch fish here? This is what I’m talking about when I speak of fishing etiquette. When I’m out on the river, and I’m sure most people would agree, I want to relax, enjoy nature, and if I can manage it, catch a few fish. I don’t need to give a fishing lesson to anyone. And, as far as I’m concerned, no one needs to give one to me. If I see you on the river and you catch a nice fish, good for you. I might give you a thumb’s up or something, but that’s all the information we need to exchange.
I’ve never understood why people think that if a fish is caught out of a spot, that’s the only place on a given stretch of water that contains fish. And the spot or area that they’re fishing doesn’t! That’s the only explanation as to why these two guys muscled up on me like a bully on the smaller kids in the schoolyard. They had to think that they had a better chance of catching a fish where I had just caught a fish than where they were originally fishing. And just to clear the air, this is not the case. It’s a fallacy, and this kind of behavior needs to stop.
Give other anglers the space they need to fish when you’re out on the river. Using a little fishing etiquette out on the water will make our sport better for all of us. As I eluded to earlier, just afford people the same courtesy you would on a busy elevator. Just because were standing in a river, it doesn’t mean we can’t practice basic etiquette.
Trevor Kugler – Co-founder of JRWfishing.com Trevor has more than 20 years of fishing experience, and now specializes in ultralight trout fishing.
4 comments
Skip to comment form
Thank you for the very nice complement Hank, I built this site as I had a dream and a goal. I had some excellent help along the way. I am very passionate about fishing, as It is a very enjoyable sport. I am glad you like the site and I hope to see you back again. Please feel free to comment on any article on the site as this is how we both gain information. Take care Hank, Mike.
Hi Mike: I know this is an old post but I was looking for some info on river etiquette and this post came up, so I thought I’d write and ask your opinion on something.
Yesterday a friend and I floated the Bow from Policeman’s to Mckinnon’s and part way down, around the 80th street access, we took a channel on the north side that we’d never tried before. We just got into it and rounded a little bend and there was a guide boat anchored on the south side of the channel with the guide and his two clients standing beside their boat fly fishing across to the north side, basically blocking the channel.
The guide spotted us right away and yelled for us not to come through while they were fishing so we jammed on the brakes with the oars and managed to stop about 30 metres upstream of them. They then kept fishing across the channel while we sat and waited. Finally after 10 minutes it was clear they weren’t going to quit anytime soon, so we pushed our boat to the south side of the channel and then pulled it along the shore and passed behind them.
The guide didn’t say anything to us, but he clearly thought we we’re being dicks for making them stop casting while we pulled our boat around them. Then we moved on about another 100 metres and stopped to do some stationary fishing ourselves. About 5 minutes later, the guide and his clients come down the channel but instead of making them stop and wait for us, we just saved them through, which they did. We didn’t get a “thank you” and the clients kept fishing right across the water we were casting into!!
My question is this: Was the guide right to make us stop and wait? Wouldn’t it have been better for them to stop fishing for a minute while we drifted through, provided we reeled in our gear and didn’t fish their water. Or were we in the wrong for wanting to get past them without waiting? This is a tough one because the channel was quite narrow and there was no way for us to pass each other without getting in each other’s way.
I know you float the Bow a lot, so I have to think you’ve run into this situation from time to time. Any thoughts?
Thanks,
Chris
Hey Chris, perfect spot to post your question as it is definitely etiquette related. In no way was the guide in the right to ask you to stop and wait. The reason why is he does not OWN the river and is in no way in the right by asking you to stop and wait. What he should have done was ask his clients to stop casting while you floated through that section of river and passed them.
Obviously you could NOT see them as you stated you rounded the bend and there they were. Also, I would say that in fact “he was the Ass*#$*” for not letting you pass in the first place. Then he pulls the loser and comes through your water and lets his clients cast to your location. That to me is just plain ignorant and totally uncalled for. This showed a total lack of class on his part and hopefully his clients never tipped him after their trip was finished.
Here is the deal for me, if I see people on the shore fishing, I row my boat away from their location as they were there first and therefore have the right of way. Once I have passed their location I will then permit my clients to cast into that side of the river but ONLY once we have passed their location. Secondly, If I was the one standing on the shoreline with clients fishing and I saw you coming through, I would have asked my clients to hold up while you passed through. I would NEVER have made you pull your boat out of the water and pass behind me on the shoreline.
It sounds to me like this so called guide needs to go to etiquette school and learn some manners before someone teaches him some out on the water !!!!
The next time that happens to you Chris, just keep floating through and then he will have no choice but to stop casting and let you through.
Just my opinion. I know I would have NOT pulled my boat out of the river for him and as you witnessed, he never pulled his out either !!!
Cheers,
~Mike.
Thanks Mike. That confirms what we thought. I’ve been in the situation where I’m on shore and a boat comes along and doesn’t see me until its too late for them to move. Usually I just stop fishing and the guides usually tell their clients to pull in their gear too while they go by. And usually I get a “sorry, didn’t see you” which is OK.
Too bad most of the guide boats aren’t marked with the company name. I’d like to call them and let them know what a low class move that was.
Chris